Criminal profiling is easy, apparently. According to this fascinating article in New Yorker, it uses the same tricks as stage psychics and other cons. Hat-tip to denialism blog.
5 Random Semi-Related Posts
Tags: cold-reading, criminology, psychology
All publication is a political act. All communication is propaganda. All art is pornography. All business is personal. All hail Eris. Vive le poisson rouge sauvages!
‹ Flickr’s 2 billionth photo • Colossus reborn! And the race is on… ›
Recent Comments
- Matt Lewandowsky on Stupid email disclaimers: don’t use them!
- jay on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Stilgherrian on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Sean Carmody on Stupid email disclaimers: don’t use them!
- Allison Reynolds on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Stilgherrian on Stupid email disclaimers: don’t use them!
- Stilgherrian on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Carol Shepherd on Stupid email disclaimers: don’t use them!
- Kate Carruthers on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- firstdog on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Stilgherrian on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Andrew E on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- DizzyStuff on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Stilgherrian on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
- Stephen Stockwell on Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
Recent Articles
-
Episode 25 online!
05 September 2008 in Stilgherrian Live
Yes, Stilgherrian Live has returned, and last night’s episode of Stilgherrian Live Delta, episode 25, is online for your (re)viewing pleasure.
I was grumpy because we started 40 minutes late. A technical fault at Ustream prevented people hearing the audio, so we just had to wait. I’m not good at waiting. I was rude. Sorry.
Still, when [...] -
Stilgherrian Live returns tonight
04 September 2008 in Notes, Stilgherrian Live
A quick reminder: Stilgherrian Live returns tonight at 9.30pm Sydney time. It’s a new one-hour format, and the Ustream link may change if I drop the “alpha”, so start looking at stilgherrian.com/live.
5 Random Semi-Related Posts
Stilgherrian Live Alpha: a program brief (4 comments)
Live (0 comments)
Here’s episode 4! (7 comments)
Stilgherrian Live Alpha: episode 1 tonight! (3 comments)
Stilgherrian [...] -
Who do you nominate for “Cnut of the Week”?
03 September 2008 in Stilgherrian Live
Stilgherrian Live, my live Internet program, returns tomorrow night, and I need nominations for this week’s “Cnut of the Week”.
If you missed the last two episodes, well, the segment “Cnut of the Week” is dedicated to the memory of King Cnut the Great, also known as Canute, a Viking ruler of England and Denmark, and [...] -
Links for 31 August 2008 through 03 September 2008
03 September 2008 in Daily Links
Stilgherrian’s links for 31 August 2008 through 03 September 2008, small in number but big in quantity:
Victorian Railways’ Telegraph Code Book | Railpage Australia: Yes, it’ what it says: the code book used by Victorian railways for sending telegraphic messages. Arum = Trucks loaded with timber.
He Said It First | YouTube: This 2.5-minute movie is [...] -
A Metal to Drag Transformation
30 August 2008 in Arts
Q: What do these two people have in common? A: They’re the same person!
The wonderful musical Hedwig and the Angry Inch is about to embark on an Australian tour. Melbourne metal performer Ezekiel Ox is performing the title role and, as this sequence of photos shows, the transformation was amazing.
Hedwig and the Angry Inch plays [...]
Original material Copyright 2006-2008 Stilgherrian. All Rights Reserved — but do contact me for generally generous reprint rights. Comments and other user-contributed material remains the property of the author.
3 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link
http://stilgherrian.com/human-nature/criminal_profiling_bunk/trackback/
15 November 2007 at 10:29 pm
Richard
This is a long-overdue article. ‘Profiling’ is a pseudoscience - file it alongside water divining and copper bracelets for rheumatism.
I’ve spent a few years in law enforcement. One mob I used to work for had a profiler - basically because it was something they’d seen on TV, and because a chauvinistic police force could be seen to place a token woman in a high-profile position. She was trained in the USA at horrendous cost to the taxpayer. She got to go on a lot of junkets, had a very comfortable office (with framed certificates, always a bad sign), and displayed near-psychopathic levels of arrogance.
The punchline: as far as I am aware, she was not responsible for one single successful investigation.
All homicide investigations in this state have been resolved through a combination of painstaking data analysis, forensic work, and targeted surveillance.
Still, I see no decline in the popularity of novels, films and TV in the ‘profiler’ genre. I suppose it’s because an emotional and intuitive character is more ‘exciting’ than a skilled and methodical one, no matter how poorly it reflects reality.
15 November 2007 at 10:36 pm
Richard
Sorry, that should be ‘all *successful* homicide investigations’ etc. PIMF.
16 November 2007 at 1:58 pm
Stilgherrian
@Richard: Thanks for that, nice to have the suspicions confirmed.
Once I really did freak someone out by “profiling” them after having met them for all of 5 minutes. I picked up enough in those few minutes to be able to go for some high-likelihood comments, which made them suitably gullible, and the rest was pretty standard cold-reading tricks.
Maybe I should go for a job in law enforcement…
Maybe after saying that I should get my head read!