A former member says workers aren’t paid and there’s no workers compensation or insurance.

[Update 25 April 2012: I'm closing comments on this post now, for the reasons given in the final comment. If you want to tell me anything more about Twelve Tribes or Common Ground Cafe, please email me.]

Story is, the police gave festival coordinator Sue Anderson three choices: fence in the event and ban BYO alcohol, pay them to provide 30 officers, or… no festival at all. With user-pays policing apparently too expensive, she went for the fence.

Sue tried to spin the decision. “It’s only a fence,” she claimed in The Drum Media Official Guide to the Newtown Festival 2006. And she said there’d be a variety of drinks to buy on site.

Wrong on both counts.

A fence isn’t only a fence. It’s also pig-ignorant private security staff unable to open their mouths fully. It’s a surly “Move to the next gate!” instead of a smile and a “Hi folks, the queue’s shorter just over there.” It’s bag searches and do as you’re told.

It’s only a fence in the same way that Israel is only building a wall — one of the most powerful symbols of exclusion society has devised. No longer is it Our Community gathering in Our Park. It’s just those community members who are acceptable to an authority following an arbitrary set of rules. Sure, it was all-in this year, but the mechanisms are now in place to clamp it down further.

A fence and a “voluntary” gold coin donation is just one step short of yet another Ticketed Day Out.

Beer? Some choice!

The promised variety of alcohol simply wasn’t there.

The beers? Two. VB or Carlton Draught. Both lagers — even though Newtown is probably the most ale-conscious part of Sydney. Both from CUB. Both shit.

The spirits? Vodka Smirnoff Red, UDL Vodka, Lime & Soda, and UDL Vodka & Orange. In other words, any spirit you like — as long as it’s vodka. And as long as it’s canned lollywatershitevodka.

Sue, none of this is your fault. You were pressured into compliance. It’s a shame you felt you had to do this.
Bar Shakespeare (nee Coopers Arms Hotel) chose their wares cluelessly. But despite this, the event was a success. Well done.

Why fence us in?

The rationale is police perception that the festival “sits on a knife edge” and “could go crazy at any moment”. There were “quite a few incidents” last year, we’re told, including a stabbing outside the Courthouse Hotel.

That’s unfortunate. But if someone commits a crime it’s their fault, whether they’re tanked up or not, and regardless of where they got pissed.

However my main problem with police pressure to fence the festival is that it’s financial blackmail. Do things our way, or don’t do them at all.

“User-pays policing” is a disturbing concept. I’m guessing it was forced upon hard-working boys and girls in blue by politicians avoiding actually spending our taxes on services. Again. Perhaps if we’re talking about for-profit events there might be some justification… but no, actually!

Banks and bookmakers are for-profit, but police investigate thefts and frauds committed against them. Owners of expensive cars or properties are likewise supported, though you could argue that they attract theft through ostentation.

Why should a community event — something so perfectly normal as a spring festival, the whole point of which is for youngfolk to burn off hormonal energy and, yes, have a few beers on a sunny Sunday afternoon — have to pay extra for policing?